A headline ROAS target is not enough to compare marketing agencies. Ask every agency to respond to the same brief, then normalize its proposal into the same rows: work included, media budget, fees, setup costs, creative and tools, conversion definition, reporting source, account ownership, business assumptions, and exit deliverables. Only then calculate how many completed new customers must cover the full cost.

This approach does not identify a guaranteed winner. It reveals where two proposals are actually different and where impressive numbers depend on different definitions. If one agency quotes platform ROAS before fees and another proposes reporting on collected revenue after cancellations, their figures are not competing answers to the same question.

If the business is not ready to give any provider a stable offer, access, outcome definitions, or an owner for decisions, start with the agency-readiness guide. If those basics exist, use the process below before choosing a partner.

Give every agency the same short brief

A fair comparison begins before the proposals arrive. Send the same facts and constraints to each provider:

  • The product, service area, eligible customer, and offer being promoted
  • The business outcome that matters, such as a completed first job or collected first order
  • Current monthly media spend and the maximum total monthly marketing budget
  • Contribution from a typical completed new customer, not only gross revenue
  • Current lead, qualification, sale, cancellation, and collection counts when available
  • Internal capacity, response process, seasonality, compliance limits, and known tracking gaps
  • The accounts, website, CRM, and creative resources already controlled by the business

Do not ask an agency to forecast from details it never received. Record omissions instead. An agency that names an assumption and proposes how to test it is giving you more usable information than one that hides uncertainty behind a precise projection.

Normalize each proposal into one sheet

Copy the proposal facts into this table. Do not let a polished deck create rows that another proposal never had a chance to answer. Send the completed sheet back to each agency and ask it to correct anything you misunderstood.

Comparison row What to record Clarifying question
Business outcome The customer event the work is expected to influence What exact event will count as success?
Scope Channels, campaigns, pages, creative, tracking, meetings, and analysis included What work is included each month, and what is extra?
Media Planned spend paid to platforms Is this separate from every agency charge?
Agency charges Retainer, percent of spend, project fees, and performance fees What triggers each charge?
Setup One-time onboarding, audit, build, migration, or tracking cost When is it billed, and what is reusable?
Other costs Creative production, software, data, call tracking, landing pages, or contractors Which costs are required, optional, or estimated?
Measurement Conversion event, revenue source, attribution method, window, and reporting schedule Which system is the source of truth when platforms disagree?
Ownership and access Owner of ad accounts, analytics, audiences, creative, domains, tags, and source files What access remains with the business during and after the contract?
Assumptions Conversion rate, sales follow-up, capacity, approval speed, and customer value Which assumption would most change the recommendation?
Exit Notice, final invoice, access transfer, files, documentation, and deletion duties What is delivered when the agreement ends?

For Google Ads work, this separation is more than tidy bookkeeping. Google's current third-party policy says Google advertising cost should be reported as the exact amount charged by Google, exclusive of third-party fees. It also requires applicable management fees to be disclosed and says customers must receive their Google Ads customer ID when requested. Use those items as concrete comparison questions, not as proof that a provider will perform well.

Translate every ROAS number before comparing it

ROAS is revenue divided by advertising cost, but a proposal can change either side of that division. Put each claimed or projected number through this definition card:

ROAS figure:
Revenue numerator: booked, invoiced, collected, or platform-attributed?
Refunds and cancellations removed: yes / no / unknown
New customers separated from existing customers: yes / no / unknown
Cost denominator: media only or full marketing cost?
Agency, setup, creative, software, and tax included: yes / no / unknown
Attribution source, model, and window:
Historical evidence used:
Assumptions that must hold:
Decision this number is allowed to support:

A platform return can be useful for managing campaigns inside that platform. It is not automatically profit, cash collected, or an apples-to-apples agency comparison. Use the ROAS is not profit guide to reconcile the numerator and denominator, and the collected-revenue guide to keep open estimates from being counted as cash.

Treat any guarantee or unusually precise performance promise as a claim that needs evidence and conditions. The U.S. Federal Trade Commission says objective advertising claims need a reasonable basis before they are published, and that a guarantee does not replace substantiation. That rule is about advertising claims, not a scoring system for agency quality, but the practical buyer question is still useful: what evidence supports this promise for a business with our offer, market, budget, sales process, and capacity?

Calculate the full-cost break-even customer count

Use one cost boundary for every proposal. A practical starting point is:

Full monthly marketing cost
= media spend
+ agency charges
+ monthly share of setup costs
+ required creative, software, data, and tracking costs

Break-even completed new customers
= full monthly marketing cost / contribution per completed new customer

Round the customer result up because a fraction of a customer cannot complete a purchase. This is a screening calculation, not a forecast. It assumes the contribution figure and included costs are appropriate for the decision. Taxes, overhead, refunds, repeat purchases, capacity, and cash timing may require a different model.

Consider two hypothetical proposals for the same local service business. The business estimates $800 of contribution from a completed first job after direct delivery costs.

Monthly cost Proposal A Proposal B
Media $6,000 $5,000
Agency charge $1,500 $2,000
Monthly share of setup $400 $0
Required creative and tools $100 $1,000
Full monthly marketing cost $8,000 $8,000
Break-even completed new customers 10 10

Proposal A may lead with a media-only ROAS target while Proposal B may avoid a ROAS forecast and emphasize customer records. Neither presentation changes the example's full cost or its break-even count. The proposals still differ in media allocation, scope, setup, creative, assumptions, and measurement. The normalized sheet lets the owner investigate those differences instead of selecting the larger-looking ratio.

If contribution is uncertain, calculate a low, working, and high case rather than hiding the uncertainty in one number. The customer-value confidence guide shows how to match budget confidence to evidence quality. You can also enter each proposal's complete cost boundary in the marketing profitability calculator.

Check ownership, reporting, and the working relationship

A proposal can have sensible economics and still create an operational trap. Before signing, confirm:

  • The business has direct, appropriate access to its core advertising and measurement accounts.
  • The named conversion can be traced from the platform or site into the business outcome record.
  • Reports will separate media spend, provider fees, and other required costs.
  • The people doing the work, the decision owner, meeting cadence, and approval deadlines are named.
  • Changes, tests, exclusions, and incidents will be logged rather than explained from memory.
  • The contract says what happens to accounts, audiences, creative, pages, tags, documentation, and source files at exit.

Google's Search Central guidance for hiring SEO recommends researching the advantages and risks of a provider and notes that an irresponsible SEO can damage a site and its reputation. Current guidance from Search Engine Land, Search Engine Journal, HubSpot, and Neil Patel also repeatedly raises goals, reporting, pricing, access, deliverables, communication, and termination. Those sources are useful topic intelligence. The normalization sheet above is designed to turn those recurring questions into one comparable owner record.

Finish with a three-state shortlist decision

Do not force a numerical ranking when material facts are missing. Give each proposal one state:

State Use it when Next action
Comparable Scope, full cost, outcome definition, access, assumptions, and exit terms are clear enough to evaluate Compare fit, evidence, risk, and economics
Clarify A material answer is missing or the definitions do not match Ask one written question for each gap, then update the sheet
Stop The provider will not separate costs, define the claimed result, disclose essential access, or put material terms in writing Remove it from the shortlist or obtain independent contract review

A lower fee does not automatically mean lower total cost. A higher forecast does not automatically mean stronger evidence. Choose the proposal whose complete terms you can understand, operate, measure, and exit, and whose assumptions fit the business records you actually have.

Once a provider is selected, use the marketing handoff checklist to prepare business-owned facts, access, metric definitions, starting conditions, and decision boundaries. If you want help turning multiple proposals into one measurement and reporting plan, review Ocean Media's strategy and reporting service.

Your next step

Talk through your marketing plan

Explore relevant Ocean Media support

Sources checked

For general education only. Platform details and examples can change. Verify important information before acting. Ocean Media Marketing is not responsible for decisions based solely on this resource. Suggest a correction